(Image source: Toyota) Shopping for a mid-size SUV can be overwhelming. With so many models to choose from, how do you figure out which one actually lives up to the hype? To help you out, we’re breaking down some of the most popular mid-size SUVs on the market—the Toyota Highlander, Honda Pilot, Kia Telluride, Ford Explorer, Hyundai Palisade, Subaru Ascent, and Mazda CX-90. We’ll look at their high points, talk about their shortcomings, and come to a verdict on whether they’re worth your hard-earned cash.
Buckle up, and let’s get into it.
Toyota Highlander
Why It’s Worth Considering
The Toyota Highlander has long been a family favorite, offering reliability, practicality, and a strong resale value. Its turbocharged 2.4L engine is peppy yet efficient, delivering up to 29 MPG combined. Inside, the Highlander seats up to 8 passengers and features a modern 12.3-inch touchscreen with wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. Toyota’s Safety Sense suite also comes standard, providing advanced driver aids, such as adaptive cruise control and lane-centering assist.
Why You Might Skip It
The Highlander doesn’t particularly stand out in any one area. Its third-row seating is cramped and better suited for kids, and the new turbocharged engine lacks the smoothness of the former V6. It’s a safe, reliable choice but doesn’t pack much excitement or personality.
Final Verdict
The Toyota Highlander is a solid option for families who prioritize reliability and safety. While it’s not the most exciting choice, it’s perfect for practicality-focused buyers.
Honda Pilot
Why It’s Worth Considering
Redesigned for 2024, the Honda Pilot boasts a more spacious interior, a rugged new look, and improved off-road capability. It features a dependable 3.5L V6 engine with 285 horsepower and increased cargo space, making it a workhorse for families. The TrailSport trim caters to adventurers with all-terrain tires and an off-road suspension, while the rest of the lineup offers refined comfort for everyday use.
Why You Might Skip It
The Honda Pilot’s starting price is a bit steep, especially considering its entry-level trims are missing some premium touches. And while the TrailSport trim is solid for light trails, serious off-roaders will likely find its capabilities limited.
Final Verdict
The Honda Pilot shines if you prioritize space, family-friendly features, and versatility. If you’re after a budget-friendly option or trail-dominating off-road capability, you may want to look elsewhere.
Kia Telluride
Why It’s Worth Considering
The Kia Telluride remains a favorite thanks to its upscale interior, bold styling, and generous features. It offers refined materials, a spacious cabin, and high-tech options, including a 12.3-inch touchscreen, available dual sunroofs, and heated/ventilated seats. Its 3.8L V6 engine produces 291 horsepower, delivering smooth, reliable performance. Combine all that with Kia’s industry-leading 10-year warranty, and you’ve got a winner.
Why You Might Skip It
High demand has led to dealer markups, so the Telluride might cost you more than its MSRP. Additionally, while its ride is smooth and refined, it’s not particularly sporty or engaging to drive. Those seeking turbocharged engines or performance-oriented handling might find it underwhelming.
Final Verdict
If you can snag one without paying extra, the Kia Telluride is absolutely worth it. It’s stylish, practical, and luxurious for the price, making it a top pick—so long as you prioritize comfort over excitement.
Ford Explorer
Why It’s Worth Considering
The Ford Explorer stands out for its performance and versatility. It offers multiple powertrain options, including a hybrid and a sporty 400-hp ST trim. Its rear-wheel-drive setup provides excellent towing capability and a confident ride, while the roomy interior features a modernized SYNC 4 infotainment system with an optional 12-inch screen.
Why You Might Skip It
Beneath its surface, the Explorer has some weak points. Base trims feel dated and uninspired, and past models have raised concerns about reliability. It’s also more of a fuel guzzler than some rivals, which might turn off eco-conscious buyers.
Final Verdict
Choose the Ford Explorer if power, towing, and sporty handling are top priorities. Otherwise, you may find better value and reliability in other SUVs.
Hyundai Palisade
Why It’s Worth Considering
The Hyundai Palisade shares many strengths with its cousin, the Kia Telluride, but adds its own spin on comfort and luxury. The 2024 Palisade boasts an elegant design with available quilted leather seats, a fully digital dashboard, and a premium sound system. Its 3.8L V6 engine delivers smooth and efficient performance, while advanced safety features and an impressive warranty sweeten the deal. Whether you’re commuting in style or road-tripping with the family, it excels at road comfort.
Why You Might Skip It
While luxurious, the Palisade can feel a bit softer in terms of handling. It’s built for comfort rather than agility, so drivers looking for a sportier feel might be left wanting. Additionally, like its cousin, high demand may lead to excessive dealer markups.
Final Verdict
The Hyundai Palisade is an excellent all-rounder, offering luxury on a mainstream budget. It’s ideal for families who value comfort, style, and tech. If agility or standout off-road capabilities are on your list, though, you might look elsewhere.
Subaru Ascent
Why It’s Worth Considering
The Subaru Ascent is a practical choice for adventure-loving families. Standard all-wheel drive, 8.7 inches of ground clearance, and Subaru’s X-MODE make it highly capable in all-weather conditions and light off-road trails. It offers seating for up to 8 passengers, ample cargo space, and an extensive suite of safety tech, including Subaru EyeSight driver assistance. Its turbocharged 2.4L engine provides a solid mix of power and efficiency, ensuring you get where you need to go in comfort.
Why You Might Skip It
The Ascent’s turbocharged engine can feel noisy under hard acceleration, and its third-row space is a bit cramped compared to segment leaders. Additionally, while it’s great for slippery trails, it doesn’t have the off-road chops to compete with rugged models like the Honda Pilot TrailSport or Ford Explorer Timberline.
Final Verdict
The Subaru Ascent is a dependable and capable choice, especially for those who regularly encounter rough weather conditions. It’s not the most exciting or rugged option, but it’s dependable, safe, and functional.
Mazda CX-90
Why It’s Worth Considering
Mazda stepped up its game in 2024 with the CX-90, offering a sophisticated design, premium materials, and engaging performance. The CX-90 leans into its luxury aspirations with an available 3.3L inline-6 turbocharged engine that delivers up to 340 horsepower. It also offers a plug-in hybrid variant for eco-conscious buyers. Inside, you’ll find a stunning cabin featuring Nappa leather, a 12.3-inch center display, and refined accents. Even better, the CX-90’s sharp handling makes it one of the most fun-to-drive SUVs in the segment.
Why You Might Skip It
All that luxury can come at a cost—literally. The Mazda CX-90’s higher trims can approach premium SUV pricing territory, which might tempt you to consider upscale brands instead. Plus, while it’s sporty on the road, it doesn’t offer much in the way of off-road ability, limiting its appeal to adventure seekers.
Final Verdict
The Mazda CX-90 is a perfect match for drivers who value style, performance, and high-end features in their SUV. If off-roading or budget-conscious pricing is more your speed, though, it might not be the best fit.
The Bottom Line
All of these SUVs bring their own strengths to the table, but your decision ultimately comes down to what you value most.
- Toyota Highlander is the go-to for reliability and family-focused practicality.
- Honda Pilot excels with space and versatility, especially for large families.
- Kia Telluride delivers premium features at a great value.
- Ford Explorer is the choice for performance and towing enthusiasts.
- Hyundai Palisade brings comfort and luxury at an affordable price.
- Subaru Ascent is perfect for families navigating rough weather or light trails.
- Mazda CX-90 shines with luxury and fun-to-drive handling.
No SUV is perfect for everyone, but there’s definitely one here that could be perfect for you. Now, which one will you test drive first?
